What is the best mattress in the Casper vs. Nectar vs. Purple mattress debate? That’s what we want to discover today in this mattress review.
Casper Sleep Memory Foam 10 Inch Mattress, Nectar Gel Memory Foam 11 Inch Mattress, and Purple Hyper-Elastic Polymer 9.5 Inch Mattress are all from new mattress brands that have barely lasted five years on the market.
- Today, they feature among the best mattresses ever courtesy of their cutting edge innovation and scientific approach to sleeping.
In this review, we have sampled the most popular mattress model from each brand and put the three of them to a contest. If you were stuck on which one to go for, this review will help you make a better purchase decision.
Luxurious cotton blend covers
Memory and poly foams
Tencel and cotton quilted with memory materials
Hyper-Elastic Polymer™ and poly foams
Viscose, polyester, and Lycra
As a queen size mattress, it is ideal for couples, and unlike what you’ve heard before about Casper, this particular model isn’t that expensive as the new Casper mattresses.
It has a 4-layer memory foam construction for support and comfort. Back, stomach and side sleepers will benefit from this mattress. The open-cell hypoallergenic latex layer aids breathability and dissipation of heat.
The material is also resistant to dust mite and dander making Casper Sleep great of allergy sufferers as well.
It tags along with a 10-year warranty and a 100-day nights trial.
As a queen size mattress, it is the right choice for The mattress also tags along with the most extended sleep trial in the market so far; 180 days when you buy via Amazon.
Regarding the construction, this is a gel memory foam mattress that is comfortable and sleeps cool.
As a queen size mattress, it is the right choice for couples and will benefit side sleepers as it is not too firm and provides just the right sinkage and relief to all the pressure points.
The Nectar Gel Memory Foam Mattress works with all types of bends including the traditional frames, box springs, and adjustable bases among others.
- It offers excellent comfort characterized by a bouncy feel and responsiveness.
As a Twin XL bed, Purple is best for the tall sleepers and will also be an excellent purchase for couples with an active sleeping pattern and those who sleep hot.
The grid design significantly reduces motion isolation and consequently, disturbance, when turning or moving out of the bed.
The mattress is also antimicrobial making it suitable for allergy sufferers and also has a unique airflow technology that hastens heat dissipation and shortens off-gassing.
Casper vs. Nectar vs. Purple: Who’s the winner?
Now that we have a few facts about the three mattress, it’s time we put them to a contest.
To help you get the most out of this review, we are going to compare them based on the important factors considered when buying mattresses.
The most important consideration when buying a mattress is the comfort it provides.
Here’s how the three brands compare.
- The top layer of this mattress has a 1-inch quilted gel-infused foam and an inch 0f 4 lb/ft gel-infused memory foam.
- The two layers provide the best responsiveness, support, and body contouring.
- It is reinforced with a 3-inch with 3.5 lb/ft gel-infused memory foam just before the support layer.
- The comfort layer of the Casper Sleep Memory Foam 10 Inch Mattress mattress has a foam similar to latex, but it is not original latex.
- It offers a slight bounce and responds to pressure instantly.
- Beneath it is another 1.5″ memory foam (3.5 lb/ft density) memory foam layer for body contouring.
- The top comfort layer of Purple Original mattress has a 2-inch high-density polymer molded in a grid pattern.
- In addition, there is 3.25 inches of 1.8 lb/ft density foam just before the support layer.
Besides comfort, support is also another crucial aspect of good sleep.
The three mattresses are memory foam mattresses and have foam as the support layer.
But is the support the same? Absolutely not because different materials have been integrated, at different thicknesses.
This mattress has a 1.5-inch 2.5 lb/ft density foam, and 5-inch 1.8 lb/ft density foam as the support layers.
Here we have 6-inch support with a 2.2 lb/ft foam. It is very firm and actually feels hard for light sleepers.
The Original series has only one support layer; 4-inches of 2 lb/ft density foam.
This is important for couples because you are sleeping on one side of the mattress only. Lack of proper edge support will make the mattress collapse on the edges when a little pressure is exerted. This is not only uncomfortable but unsafe as well for babies.
Let us review the edge support for the three mattresses.
This mattress has quite an excellent edge support, and even though there is a roll-off feeling on the edges, the collapsed section is not so deep because the comfort layer is not so thick. Sitting on one area collapses the comfort layer. The overall feel is better edge support because the support layer is near the surface.
This on is not so different from Nectar. It also has a roll-off sensation when you sleep on the very edge. It is the comfort layers that collapse here and good enough, the hard support layer is not very far. When the mattress is new, the edge support is firm.
This mattress comes with what looks like firm edges but they when a little pressure is exerted. I would say that Casper’s edges collapse almost the entire comfort layer but becomes firm when you reach the support layer if you sit on a specific area. But sleeping on the edge is different as the weight is distributed across. The mattress feels stiff and sturdy enough so unless it crunches a few years, expect steady edge support.
There are so many ways that the firmness of a mattress can be described, but in simple terms, it’s how hard or soft a mattress feels.
So, what firmness levels do these three mattresses offer?
This mattress is not too hard or too soft and is the perfect definition of a medium-firm mattress. Nectar mattress has one firmness level rated between 5.5 and 7.5 by the company, but in practice, we put it at 6. The mattress layers are hard enough to keep your weight afloat and the spine aligned, and at the same time, it is soft to relieve pressure
This mattress also has a medium-firm firmness score, but this time, we ranked it 6.5 meaning it’s a little bit firmer. The polymer grid collapses by a definite measure regardless of your weight. It is an excellent option for heavy sleepers but for the light guys; they may not have the required pressure to collapse the grids, and that will make Purple a little bit hard.
This mattress has a much similar feel to what Purple offers. Here again, heavy sleepers (230 lbs.) will feel the mattress is just fine, with the right sinkage. However, light sleepers below 150lbs. find the mattress a little bit hard. This was in tandem with the 6.5 score we gave it on a firmness scale of 10. But this is when it was new. After a few months of use, when the body gets fully used to it, Casper becomes more comfortable.
5. Temperature neutrality
This is all about the ability of a mattress to maintain a cool sleeping surface despite the heat your body releases.
- The material and construction greatly determine the temperature neutrality of mattresses.
So, which is the best mattress for hot sleepers?
The Nectar mattress comes with a layer of gel infused open cell foam. The advantage of gel is that it dissipates heat faster. On the other hand, the open cell structure makes sure the mattress can efficiently circulate air and consequently fasten heat dissipation. On the top, the Tencel cover circulates air and wicks out heat.
This mattress also uses open cell foam that greatly enhances air circulation. The proprietary latex dissipates heat but not as efficiently as gel foam. The thin cover, on the other hand, is perforated to allow for efficient air circulation.
This mattress doesn’t sleep hot at all, and we understand that this is largely because of the polymer grid structure that leaves air pockets where heat dissipates. Above all, this is a gel layer which is known to dissipate heat faster than other foams. There is also a thin, breathable cover that ensures air circulates in and out of the mattress freely.
So, which of the three brands has the most off-gassing?
There is no much off-gassing with the Casper original, but the new Casper Wave will leave a strong bad odor even after days. As long as you leave the mattress in a well-ventilated room for 48 hours, there will be very little off-gassing after that.
Also this mattress is good for allergy sufferers as it doesn’t release any bad odor past two days. Just make sure it is in a ventilated room, and that’s it.
This mattress leaves a foul smell long after the 48 hours promised. You need to be patient with this mattress for the odor to fade away. But that is not to say that the materials are substandard; Purple mattresses are CertiPUR-US certified.
7. Motion isolation
This refers to the disturbance on the mattress surfaces created when intense pressure is applied to one part of the mattress.
Active sleepers need to consider mattresses with reduced motion isolation to minimize the chances of waking up your partner, or even yourself when you move around the bed.
So, which is the best mattress for active sleepers?
When turning on the Nectar mattress, there is minimal noise and ripples on the mattress surface. Your spouse or sleeping partner will hardly feel the disturbance.
This mattress brand is also known for reduced motion isolation. The foam material absorbs energy and will hardly create disturbance in the middle of the night.
The grid pattern collapse in accordance with the weight emulating an innerspring mattress or hybrid. You can hardly feel any disturbance on the side when someone sits or sleeps on the other side of the mattress.
8. Shopping and delivery
There are mattress brands that are available in offline stores and online stores, but some are exclusively sold online.
Another thing you need to know is that brands have different delivery terms.
- Make sure the mattress can be delivered to your region, in what time and at what cost.
Some brands offer white glove service, and this includes setting up your bed and even disposing of the old mattress.
The Nectar mattress is available online on the company website, and even though this was the only place to order a Nectar mattress, the brand is on Amazon as well at great discounts. There are no brick-and-motor stores so shoppers can’t try the mattress. The mattress comes compressed, and vacuum sealed but doesn’t come in a box. Instead, it has a protective carrier bag. The company offers free shipping in all states except a few in the periphery like Alaska and Hawaii. White glove service is also available at a cost.
This mattress is available on the official Casper website and the major online retailers. There are also local retailers who stock Casper mattresses. The Casper mattress will be shipped directly to customers compressed and in a box. The company facilitates free delivery and free returns as well, but there are some regions that this service is paid for. Casper also offers white glove delivery at an extra cost, and this includes in-home mattress set up and old mattress removal.
Purple mattresse are available online but not in local stores so still buyers can’t have a feel of the mattress. Purple mattress comes compressed, and vacuum sealed and in a box making it a true mattress-in-a-box. The Purple mattress is shipped in the entire US except for the peripheries as well. There is no free white glove delivery with this mattress, but with the new Purple, you get free white glove delivery that includes in-home setup and old mattress disposal.
9. Warranty & Sleep Trials
A warranty makes you eligible for a mattress replacement or refund in case you discover the mattress had a manufacturing defect.
As for sleep trials, this is a period you can test the mattress to make sure that you really like it.
So, how does Casper, Purple, and Nectar compare here?
This mattress comes with a 10-year warranty that has no major restrictions. The brand also offers a 100-day sleep trial with no mandatory 30-day break in period. That means you can return the mattress anytime within the 100 days trial as long as it is a valid case and the mattress is in good condition.
With the Purple mattress, you also get the industry-standard ten years warranty accompanied by 100 days sleep trial. If you don’t like the mattress, you can as well return it for a refund or exchange. The warranty is non-prorated so make sure to find out what it covers and what it doesn’t.
This is the mattress brand with the longest sleep trial; 365 days. This is when you buy from the company website, but on Amazon, you get 180 days. When it comes to the warranty, it has a lifetime warranty, but that doesn’t mean a thing because the mattress won’t last more than ten years.
Casper vs. Nectar vs. Purple: which is the best mattress?
Having looked at the three mattresses, it’s time we declare the winner.
Below, we discussed some of the common sleeping needs and recommended the best mattress for each need.Budget buyer For a mattress like Casper, it is clear that you will spend a fortune to get it in your bedroom. That is already off the budget buyer’s wish list.
The battle is between Nectar Gel Memory Foam 11 Inch Mattress vs. Purple Hyper-Elastic Polymer 9.5 Inch Mattress, and it is the latter that offers the most affordable mattress.
- So, if you are on a budget, look for your next mattress from Nectar.
Here you are spoilt for choice as all the three mattresses are great for back sleepers.
- However, Casper Sleep Memory Foam 10 Inch Mattress is the perfect medium firm so it should be number one on your priority list.
Here a medium-firm mattress with a gel foam is the best.
- Nectar and Purple are good options, but the responsiveness of Nectar makes it the best.
When buying mattresses for side sleepers, more emphasizes should be on comfort as opposed to support.
- Either Casper Sleep Memory Foam 10 Inch Mattress or Purple Hyper-Elastic Polymer 9.5 Inch Mattress will do because of the soft firmness they have.
- When it comes to edge support, Nectar is the real deal because it boasts a thick 6-inch 2.2 lb/ft foam which makes the edges firmer.
- Sleepers with back pains and other symptoms that require pressure relief will get the best service from Purple mattress.
The polymer grid design hugs the body, especially on the pressure points. Casper and Nectar are also ideal in such conditions.
That’s all we had for today in this Casper Sleep Memory Foam 10 Inch Mattress vs. Nectar Gel Memory Foam 11 Inch Mattress vs. Purple Hyper-Elastic Polymer 9.5 Inch Mattress mattress comparison review.
We hope that you can now make the right purchase decision yourself.
Which is your best choice? Is it Casper, Purple or the cheap Nectar? Talk to us in the comments section below.