In this Beautyrest vs. Kingsdown vs. Casper comparison review, we have lined up the best mattresses from the three brands. Find out more about the individual brands, features that each mattress comes with, and, importantly, the best mattress for you.
Last update on 2021-11-24 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
Is Beautyrest a Good Brand?
Beautyrest is an American mattress brand owned and operated by the larger Simmons Bedding Company. Beautyrest mattresses have been top sellers in the mattresses industry for decades. The reason for the company’s success is simple – the mattresses are of high quality and durable.
What’s more? The prices are fair. Below are the highlights of the Beautyrest mattresses in this comparison review.
The Beautyrest Silver BRS900 is a pretty comfortable 12-inch mattress with the perfect lumbar support for sleepers with back pains. This is an innerspring mattress available in four firmness levels: extra firm, medium., medium-firm, and plush.
Inside the BRS900, the mattress boasts the 900 Series Beautyrest® Pocketed Coil® Technology. These coils have been optimized for optimum motion isolation and, importantly, comfortable conforming support all night long.
For comfort and lumbar support, Beautyrest designed this mattress with AirCool and Gel Memory Foam, a combination that conforms to all your body curves. The two layers are also designed to promote airflow for temperature regulation so you can sleep cool even during those hot summer nights.
For the record, this mattress can’t be flipped.
On the edges, the BRS900 comes with BeautyEdge Foam for consistent support and comfort. At the top, you get a DualCool™ Technology that consists of a dual-layer cover that is easy to maintain and has an antimicrobial layer to keep the mattress fresh and cool always.
As the name suggests, the BRX1000-C is a 13″ hybrid mattress that consists of coils for support and foam layers for comfort. Just like the BRS900, this mattress offers excellent lumbar support and comfort. The firmness of the BRX1000-C is plush.
When it comes to the support layer, this mattress comes with Beautyrest’s Pocketed Coil® Technology that tags along with 1000 Series Pocketed Coils. As for the comfort layers, the Beautyrest Hybrid 13″ BRX1000-C combines several layers of foam.
Worth mentioning is the ContourFit Design that helps sleepers find the optimal sleeping position. Its superior stretch and recovery surface adapt to your body shape throughout the night with excellent pressure relief.
To further enhance comfort, this mattress features AirCool Gel Memory Foam that allows sleepers to enjoy a peaceful night by combining the cooling properties of gel foam and the open cell structure for maximum airflow.
Even during hot summer nights, hot sleepers are guaranteed sufficient cooling courtesy of the Cool-to-the-Touch Fabric.
Is Kingsdown a Good Brand?
Kingsdown is another popular mattress brand known for its great craftsmanship for over a century. The company owned and operated by Owen & Company Limited prides itself in manufacturing mattresses that offer scientifically proven personalized support and comfort.
Below are the highlights of the two Kingsdown mattresses in this comparison review.
The Kingsdown Passions Aspiration is a 14-inch innerspring mattress that offers firm comfort.
The mattress is great for sleepers looking for a solid mattress that offers excellent support and comfort. While it is available in various sizes, we have the Cal King variant in this comparison review.
The support layer of this mattress consists of 904 (Q) Tri-Zoned individually wrapped coils that conform to your body shape while reducing motion transfer.
There are also perimeter coils with Tri-Zoned support that reinforce the mattress along the edges. This is alongside a center foam rail that also diminishes motion transfer.
As for the comfort layer, Kingsdown engineered this mattress with gel-infused foams and fibers that offer excellent pressure relief while dissipating heat. There are also specialty foams with airflow technology to further enhance cooling by maximizing airflow.
The Kingsdown Passions Imagination Pillowtop is quite similar to the Kingsdown Passions Aspiration Firm. But as the name suggests, this one is plush and has a 13.5″ thickness. Here again, you get plenty of sizes and comfort levels to choose from, but for this review, we have captured the Cal King plush variant.
When it comes to the support layer, the Kingsdown Passions Imagination features 904 (Q) Tri-Zoned layered carefully to conform to your body shape for individualized comfort and support through the night.
Besides support, these coils cut down motion transfer, together with the center form rail. To guarantee long-lasting edge support, this mattress comes with perimeter coils with Tri-Zoned Support.
The biggest difference between the Kingsdown Passions Imagination Pillowtop vs. Kingsdown Passions Aspiration Firm is comfort. Kingsdown crafted the Pillowtop with gel-infused memory foam mattress memory foam, plush foam, and convoluted plush foam.
As for cooling, there are no differences between the two models as they both have specialty foams that allow unrestricted airflow for maximized cooling.
Is Casper a Good Brand?
Casper is an award-winning mattress brand that also manufactures other bedding, including pillows and sheets. The company prides itself in delivering the best products to the market, products crafted using high-quality materials to guarantee comfort and, importantly, durability.
While it is a fairly new brand, launched in 2014, Casper is a market leader courtesy of its huge investment in R&D. Below are two of the most popular mattresses from the American brand.
The Casper Sleep Original Foam is among the best mattresses from Casper. For the record, there is a 2019 model and an updated model released in 2020. The new model is available in several sizes and medium-firm firmness.
This mattress has been crafted to suit all types of sleepers, whether they want comfort, support, or cooling.
Under the hood, the Casper Sleep Original Foam comes with memory foam support with 3 areas of Zone Support for the perfect alignment of the spine.
The base is solid to prevent sinking and sagging, one of the biggest problems many mattress brands have failed to achieve.
When it comes to the comfort layer, Casper crafted this mattress with high-quality softer foam that offers a relief-plush feel to the upper body. As for the lower body, there is firmer foam that cushions the hips, lower back, and waist region. To ensure proper cooling, Casper designed this mattress with perforated breathable foam.
The Casper Sleep Nova is also a foam mattress, available in different sizes. You can rely on this mattress if you want maximum pressure relief.
The Nova Foam is a 12-inch mattress with a plush feel. It’s suitable for sleepers looking for support, comfort, and a night of cool sleep.
Inside the mattress, there is a solid support layer engineered using high-quality foam that doesn’t sink or sag. The foam conforms with your body and sufficiently supports your entire weight through the night.
When it comes to comfort, the Casper Nova Foam boasts seven zones of targeted support for proper spine alignment. There is also softer foam for the upper body and multiple ergonomic points that offer pressure relief on the shoulders, waist, hips, and lower back.
As for cooling, Casper designed the Nova Foam with AirScape Technology, a technology that leverages perforated foam and air channels for proper air circulation.
Beautyrest vs. Kingsdown vs. Casper Face to Face Comparison Review
Now that we know a few things about the brands in this comparison review and the individual mattresses reviewed let’s get to the finer details. We will analyze all the crucial factors considered when choosing the best mattress for you. These are specifications such as size, support, conformity, materials used, firmness, and so on. Find out how Casper compares to Kingsdown and Beautyrest.
What Mattress Sizes Do Casper, Kingsdown, and Beautyrest Offer?
The first thing you need to know when shopping for a mattress is the different mattress sizes. A good mattress brand offers multiple mattress sizes. That’s what the three brands in this comparison review have done.
All the six mattresses in this review are available in all the standard sizes. These are Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King, Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King. So, whether you want just a small guest bed or a bed for you and your spouse, all these brands have something for you.
But we like Kingsdown because it gives consumers additional options. The Kingsdown Passions Aspiration and Kingsdown Passions Imagination have packages that come with box springs available in full, full extra long twin, twin extra long, and Cal King 9″ box springs.
Comfort and Support
The two most important considerations when choosing mattresses are comfort and support. These two dynamics determine whether you will be waking up with body aches and pains or you will enjoy your sleep. Find out which brand amongst Casper vs. Kingsdown vs. Beautyrest offers the best comfort and support.
Which Mattress Brand Guarantees Comfort?
Comfort, also known as pressure relief, is another critical consideration. The mattress should conform to your body shape to offer pressure relief to the main body pressure hotspots. So, what’s the most comfortable mattress brand in this Casper vs. Beautyrest vs. Kingsdown comparison review?
Candidly speaking, the three brands offer excellent comfort compared to the cheap brands out there. They may be expensive, but they meet the sleeper’s comfort. However, Casper Sleep Original Foam Mattress and Casper Sleep Original Foam Mattress carry the day. These are foam mattresses with no coils or springs. They have 3 areas for zone support and are softer around the shoulder area. On a scale of 10, Casper leads in terms of comfort with 8.5, followed by Beautyrest and Kingsdown with 8.2, and 8.0 respectively.
How About Support?
Mattress support is an essential consideration if you don’t want a mattress that will start sagging in just a few months. Mattress support is all about the ability of the mattress to push up against the weight of your body. But then, that doesn’t mean you want a firm of stonelike mattress support. Ideally, the mattress should be able to contour around your body precisely. So, what’s the best mattress for support?
While some memory foam mattresses guarantee support during the first few years, they tend to start sagging faster than their innerspring counterparts.
That said, the battle here is between Kingsdown vs. Beautyrest. When it comes to innerspring mattresses, the coil structure is the most important consideration. Any mattress with 900 – 1000 individually packed coils is good to go. But it’s not just about the number of coils – the coil gauge matters too. Both Kingdown and Beautyrest come with 15-gauge coils.
When assessing support, it’s also important to look at the edge support. Here again, memory foams don’t guarantee the longevity of steady edge support.
So, if you often sit on the edge of your bed, consider innerspring mattresses. You understand how a bed with sagged edges sucks.
As far as support goes, the Beautyrest Hybrid 13″ BRX1000-C Plush is the best choice, courtesy of the 1000 series pocketed coil technology. But you can still go for the Beautyrest Silver BRS900, a cheaper alternative to the Beautyrest Hybrid 13″ BRX1000-C. The two Kingsdown mattresses also guarantee excellent support as they both come with high-profile coils.
What is the Best Firmness for a Mattress?
To round up the discussion around the comfort and support of Casper, Beautyrest, and Kingsdown mattresses, we need to understand one aspect, mattress firmness.
Firmness is all about how soft or hard the mattresses are. To guarantee your comfort, it’s important to understand the different firmness scales.
Below is our exclusive firmness scale to help you buy the right bed.
|Mattress Firmness||Scale||Best for||Best mattress brand|
|Soft||1-2||Light and small-bodied sleepers, and side sleepers||Casper Sleep Nova Foam|
|Medium soft||3-4||Lightweight sleepers, side sleepers, combo sleepers, couples||Kingsdown Passions Imagination Pillowtop
Casper Sleep Original Foam
|Medium-firm||5-7||Heavy sleepers, back sleepers, combo sleepers, couples, sleepers with back pain||Beautyrest Hybrid 13" BRX1000-C
Kingsdown Passions Aspiration Firm
|Firm||8-10||Heavy sleepers, back sleepers, stomach sleepers, sleepers with back pain||Beautyrest Hybrid 13" BRX1000-C
Kingsdown Passions Aspiration Firm
To set the record straight, there is no such thing as the best firmness for a mattress. Here again, what may work for one sleeper as the best firmness level may be a nightmare for others.
Debunking the Myths Around Mattress Comfort, Firmness, and Support
For the record, there’s no such thing as the best mattress for comfort and support.
What might work for you might not work for another person. So, here are a few buying suggestions based on the different types of sleepers.
- Side Sleepers – If you sleep on your side, you want a mattress that conforms to your meandering body shape. Innerspring mattresses offer better conformity and contouring around your body, thus offering better pressure relief. Here, we recommend either the Kingsdown Passions Imagination Pillowtop or Beautyrest-BRX1000-C.
- Back Sleepers – If you sleep on your back, a memory foam mattress is a good idea as it offers a balance between support and conformity. Here, we front the Casper Sleep Original Foam Mattress or Casper Sleep Nova Foam Mattress. But still, Kingdown and Beautyrest mattresses are equally good, as long as you select the right thickness.
- Stomach Sleepers – Stomach sleepers should settle for nothing less than a firm mattress with excellent support. Here, innerspring mattresses are the best. In particular, 1000 Series Firm Pocketed Coils move individually to conform to your body contours. Any of the Kingsdown mattresses in this review will also be a great choice.
- Combination Sleepers – For those who sleep on their back, side, or stomach, it can be hard to settle for a mattress as you want a mix of comfort and support. However, experts recommend going for innerspring mattresses if you are a combo sleeper. Beautyrest Hybrid 13″ BRX1000-C is a good choice as it combines a heavy-duty coil profile for excellent support and a contour-fit design.
- Best Mattress for Sex – If you are looking for the best mattress for sex, innerspring or hybrid mattresses are the best. This is simply because the coils provide that bouncy feel. That said, the battle is between Kingsdown vs. Beautyrest. Here it’s hard to call a winner because the mattresses of these companies have that bounce.
As mentioned earlier, comfort and support are two of the most important considerations when comparing mattresses. Besides these two aspects, there are a few extras that should advise your purchase decision.
Mattress Cooling and Temperature Regulation?
When it comes to engineering mattresses, companies invest heavily in R&D to ensure that the mattress maintains regular temperature. If you are a hot sleeper, then you need to find a mattress that sleeps cool to reduce the hot flashes that keep you awake and uncomfortable.
So, What’s the Best Mattress for Hot Sleepers?
- Kingsdown doesn’t have the best cooling properties apart from the gel memory foam. That means the battle for the best mattress for hot sleepers is between Casper vs. Beautyrest. Both brands have high-tech cooling technologies.
- Casper’s cooling technology dubbed AirScape is designed to increase airflow and circulate air so you can always sleep cool, even during hot summer nights.
- Beautyrest also has similar technology that uses AirCool Gel Memory Foam, Gel Touch Foam, and a Cool-to-the-Touch Fabric to guarantee a cool sleep.
Here, it’s hard to call a winner between Beautyrest vs. Casper. Any mattress from the two brands befits hot sleepers.
What’s the Best Mattress for Allergy Sufferers?
Mattresses are crafted using a range of materials that may have properties that can trigger allergies. That said, when looking for the best mattress for allergy sufferers, consider offgassing.
Besides offgassing, make sure that the mattress has antimicrobial properties. Candidly speaking, all mattresses will offgass when opened. But then, the top brands guarantee just a short period of offgassing, say 24 to 48 hours after opening the mattress.
We are glad all the brands in this comparison review have mattresses that emit a bad odor for an average of 24 hours.
But then, Beautyrest comes out on top as the best mattress for allergy sufferers. This is courtesy of the Dual Cool Cover with an antimicrobial performance layer that always keeps your mattress fresh and cool. The Beautyrest Silver BRS900 will be a superb purchase here.
Which is the Best Mattress for Motion Isolation?
It can be annoying if your sleeping partner is the type that repeatedly turns on a single night. If you want a sleepless night, you should buy a mattress with the best motion isolation.
Memory foam mattresses are not ideal for motion isolation, so Casper is out of the picture. When it comes to motion isolation, innerspring mattresses are the best. The coils tend to withstand the motion created when a sleeper is turning. That said, the battle is between Beautyrest vs. Kingsdown.
The two brands have innerspring mattresses that are great when it comes to motion isolation.
But then, it’s Kingsdown that wins this contest as it comes with 904 (Q) Tri-Zoned individually wrapped coils, so the motion isolation is definitely better as the coils are individually packed and wrapped.
What’s the Best Environmentally-Friendly Mattress?
The manufacture of mattresses is a disaster to the environment. In their production, petroleum-based products are used on a large scale. What’s more? The waste mattresses that end up in landfills are a time bomb. That said, you need to consider buying from an environmentally friendly mattress brand?
But the big question is, what’s an environmentally friendly mattress brand? Well, it’s simple, the brand should manufacture their mattresses with chemicals that have no impact on the ozone layer. You should be on the lookout for certification marks from organizations such as CertiPUR-US®, OEKO-TEX®, Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS), Global Organic Latex Standard (GOLS), and USDA Organic, among others.
In this Casper vs. Kingsdown vs. Beautyrest comparison review, it’s hard to call a winner as the three brands manufacture environmentally friendly mattresses. But ultimately, it’s a close tie between Casper vs. Beautyrest. These two brands can make arrangements for disposing of your bold mattress so it won’t end up in the landfills.
Shipping and Delivery
One of the most important factors to consider when buying mattresses is shipping and delivery. If you are a modern shopper, you understand that buying online is the real deal. You don’t have to go through the hassles of visiting the local stores. All you have to do is shop for the right mattress online and enjoy the convenience of home delivery and even white glove services.
As the name suggests, white glove delivery is a special program that brands have. These premium services do everything for the mattress buyer. These extras include expedited shipping, complete mattress installation, and even the disposal of the old mattress. But then, these services differ from one brand to another. The retailers also matter.
When buying your mattress, you should also have a clear picture of when you are likely to receive your mattress. Mattress brands and retailers deliver to almost every part of the United States, but of course, there are a few exceptions. Make sure the mattress you are buying can be delivered to your region. You don’t want to get stuck when you are finalizing the purchase.
Besides the ETA of your delivery, you should also mind about how it will be delivered. As for the delivery ETA, give it 2-3 days unless you go for expedited shipping. For the record, customized mattresses may take longer, up to 15 days.
When it comes to shipping costs, the data varies from one brand and retailer to another. Some retailers and brands offer free shipping, while others put a fee for the delivery.
Aftersales Services: Returns, and Sleep Trials
When buying a mattress, make sure the brand has the best aftersales. Here, the first thing to look for is the warranty and what it stipulates. Importantly find out what types of defects are eligible for returns. Another great feature is the sleep trial. Mattress brands offer buyers sleep trial warranties.
The best brands offer up to 100 days of sleep trial.
Casper vs. Kingsdown vs. Beautyrest: Shipping, Delivery Services, and Aftersales
So, how do the three brands compare in terms of shipping and delivery? Let’s find out.
- Beautyrest mattresses are shipped within the contiguous United States. The company offers White Glove delivery at no extra costs. Unfortunately, it takes longer to receive your Beautyrest mattress. It could take even weeks. When it comes to after-sales services, Beautyrest really excels. First, the company offers a 100 days free trial. In the event you won’t be comfortable with your Beautyrest mattress, you are free to file for an exchange or full refund.
- Casper also offers excellent shipping and delivery courtesy of free shipping on most products within the contiguous United States. When it comes to the turnaround, Casper orders are shipped within 1 to 2 days. Casper memory foam mattresses arrive compressed in a plastic bag. The company also offers a 100 days sleep trial and a generous 10 years warranty on defects.
- Kingsdown doesn’t have complimentary shipping and delivery for several reasons. First, the company doesn’t have white glove delivery as a company, but some retailers have the offer. Others charge nothing, while others will put a charge on your order’s shipment. Every other thing, including the sleep trial, return policy delivery turnaround, and warranty, is set by the retailer. But the good thing is that Kingsdown mattresses are delivered on time.
When it comes to the quality of aftersales, the battle is between Casper vs. Beautyrest. Both brands square out equally but considering you will get your Casper mattress earlier; it’s the ultimate winner.
Beautyrest vs. Kingsdown vs. Casper: What’s the Best Mattress For You?
There you have it, folks, a detailed comparison of Casper vs. Beautyrest vs. Kingsdown.
As you have seen, the Casper models in this comparison, the Casper Sleep Original Foam Mattress and Casper Sleep Nova Foam Mattress are both memory foam mattresses. They guarantee the best comfort and pressure relief.
On the other hand, the Kingsdown and Beauty mattresses in this review are hybrid mattresses, also known as innerspring mattresses. The advantage of innerspring mattresses is excellent support, another crucial aspect that determines whether you will have a peaceful sleep or not.
So, which way to go? Like we said earlier, there is no such thing as the best mattress: sleepers are different. Some sleepers will be comfortable on memory foam mattresses, while for others, the innerspring mattresses are the real deal!